Menu - Mr Yum

Co-owners of Maybe Sammy Stefano Catino and Vince Lombardo are known for pizza – they have two Maybe Frank pizza joints, one in Surry Hills and another in Randwick). But there’s always been a strong booze focus thanks to the group’s creative director, Andrea Gualdi, who won the 2017 Australian Bartender Of The Year award at the respected Diageo Reserve World Class Competition.

The space has plenty of green, pastels and gold, and bartenders kitted out in pale-pink dinner jackets. Like Maybe Frank, Maybe Sammy gets its name from old Vegas posters, which read: “Dean Martin, maybe Frank [Sinatra], maybe Sammy [Davis Jnr]”, referring to the singers’ reputations for arriving unannounced for Dean Martin shows. The cocktail list, designed by Gualdi, also features drinks named after famous locations on the Vegas strip.

There’s a rotating tasting menu of $10 classic cocktails served in mini form. Named after the Rat Pack, there’s the Mini Martini (vodka or gin; olive or citrus), The Frank (Wild Turkey rye, dry vermouth, bitter Campari), The Sammy (Never Never gin, mint, sweet and dry vermouth) and The Dean (Plantation five-year rum, Calvados, Swedish punch).

It’s the show-stopping New Frontier that’s likely to get all the attention, though. The drink is made with Calle 23 Blanco Tequila, Derrumbes mezcal, fino sherry and apple, and is served with a clear inflated goon-like bag that’s popped on arrival to release a whiff of coffee essence and a scratchy that could win you a free bar snack.

The menu features oysters with mandarin granita, cheese and charcuterie, and pretty tacos served with lavender-marinated salmon, crème fraiche and avocado.

Contact Details

Updated: October 13th, 2022

We do not seek or accept payment from the cafes, restaurants, bars and shops listed in the Directory – inclusion is at our discretion. Venue profiles are written by independent freelancers paid by Broadsheet.