Food & DrinkJosh and Julie Niland’s New Waterloo Fish Butchery Offers a Blueprint To Change the Way We Eat Fish
Words by Ariela Bard · Updated on 09 Feb 2022 · Published on 07 Feb 2022
“People see Saint Peter, and the work that we do there, as gnarly. I’ve put fish sperm on plates and eyeballs in the form of crackers in front of people,” Josh Niland tells Broadsheet. “But it had to be provocative to get people’s attention.”
If all that noise at Saint Peter ’s Oxford Street premises and on Instagram was designed to make us pay attention to Niland and his wife and business partner Julie Niland, they succeeded. And now that they have us hooked, they want us to change the way we eat fish – they believe that if they take a fish out of the water, it is their duty to use every bit of it.
“Until we all collectively start thinking about quality over quantity and start using more of one single fish instead of taking two, we will have issues,” says Niland, whose latest cookbook, Take One Fish: The New School of Scale-to-Tail Cooking and Eating , was released last year. “It’s a huge wheel to stop and start spinning the other way.”
In the five years since Saint Peter opened, the couple has launched three more venues. First came the upmarket Fish Butchery in Paddington, then Charcoal Fish – the chook-shop-inspired joint that brought a legion of Instagrammers to the dog beach on Rose Bay – and, last week, Fish Butchery Waterloo, their largest (it’s roughly three times the size of the Paddington shop) and most ambitious venture yet. Along the way, Niland also became the only Australian ever to win the internationally prestigious James Beard book of the year award
The Waterloo space, which occupies an eye-catching corner position on Bourke Street, offers both retail and takeaway. And while it’s definitely not your average neighbourhood fish’n’chipper, it’s more approachable than its elegant Paddington counterpart, which feels more like a jewellery store than a fish shop. The sprawling space also acts as the central depot for processing the fish that goes out to the Nilands’ other venues, allowing the team even greater potential to mitigate waste.
“We take the cuts that suit the menu at Saint Peter and split the remainder of the fish between the other venues,” Niland says. “We’re creating businesses to facilitate different sections of the fish. Thinking of fish more like meat gives you extremely broad potential to get to that 95 per cent holy grail of usability.”
The striking floor-to-ceiling glass windows and wraparound counter seating (dining in is due to start in March) are in line with the team’s commitment to transparency, allowing passers-by and customers to see Niland’s team preparing the fish to order along a 13-metre marble counter.
Niland hopes being transparent about how his venues operate will help customers understand why his prices are higher than at your average fish’n’chip shop.
“We know how responsibly sourced every piece of fish is. Everything is meticulously handled and manicured to the point that the buyer can go home, put it in the pan, and get to rock-star the kind of experience you would get in a restaurant,” Niland says.
He says he’d love to see the brunch from Saint Peter make its way to Waterloo, and outdoor seating is in the pipeline. In the meantime, the takeaway menu has launched with some “pretty wild” options.
Take the souvlaki. Niland threads thin slices of Murray cod that have been marinated in oregano, garlic and lemon onto a vertical rotisserie, where they spin before being sliced and served in house-made flatbread with garlic sauce and chips – it’s a gyros that tastes nothing like 3am on Oxford Street. From the “pie box” order a meat pie made with yellowfin tuna mince, caramelised onion and black-pepper gravy; a rosemary and garlic fish sausage roll; or a smoked Murray cod quiche Lorraine.
The yellowfin tuna cheeseburger is a beloved transplant from Charcoal Fish, and has emerged even better than its eastern suburbs precursor. At Charcoal Fish the burger is a double – but at Waterloo you can choose between a single, double or a triple, plus you can add smoked Murray-cod bacon. And the sandwich menu includes banh mi with scallop mortadella, pressed cod-head terrine and cod-liver parfait, and a coral trout coronation sandwich.
The Nilands are also selling a range of condiments: octopus XO, harissa, gentleman’s relish, yoghurt tartare sauce, rendered Murray-cod fat and cod-liver parfait. Two large fridges that sit between 11 and 14 degrees are full of rock oysters from, among other places, Wapengo and Tathra.
The fish counter showcases a selection of fresh and dry-aged fish by the Nilands’ network of fishers, including Bruce Collis, Walker Seafoods, Luke Buchholz and Ben Collison. There are sausages, butterflied fish, tuna schnitzels, fillets of fish and ribs of tuna. Above the display is a charcuterie cabinet, home to Murray-cod bacon, tuna bresaola, swordfish pancetta, smoked tuna “ham on the bone”, moonfish prosciutto, a range of salamis and chorizo.
“People can come in, order a grilled piece of fish, add a salad or chips and watch it getting grilled on the barbeque while they wait,” says Niland. “And there’s great stuff for the kids – battered fish, scallops and onion rings; all the favourites, including the chips.” And he would know. As well as opening four venues in five years, the Nilands have had four children in the past eight.
The wall of handmade frozen goods seems to promise both quality and a quick fix, two things that usually cancel each other out. Piled neatly onto the shelves are packs of prawn dumplings, family- and individual-sized pies, tuna lasagne, sausage rolls and Murray-cod fish fingers that have been twice baked so they “won’t go floppy when you finish them off at home”.
Bread baked in-house is set to start within the first month of trade, and private events and Niland-led masterclasses are on the cards, too.
“We are not in the business of shock and awe,” Niland says of his newest venture. “It’s about deep, satisfying comfort and about trying to create a blueprint for not only those in Australia to follow but also for others to follow globally.”
Fish Butchery Waterloo
965 Bourke Street, Waterloo
Hours:
Wed to Sat 10am–7pm
Sun 10am–6pm
More from Broadsheet
Videos
More Guides
Recipes