When the Hellenic Club first opened on Elizabeth Street in the late 1950s, it became a meeting place for celebrating and continuing Greek culture in a new country. Peter Conistis first opened his much-loved modern Greek diner Alpha, which was funded by the club, a couple of doors down in 2013, and now, after a multi-million-dollar refurbishment, his cavernous diner is open once again.
Conistis opened his first restaurant, Cosmos, in 1993, which he followed up with highly regarded Eleni’s (it took over the Cosmos space) and Omega.
“When I was four years old, my mother said to me, ‘food is happiness’,” Conistis tells Broadsheet. “The menu [at Alpha] is expansive. My ethos has always been to overfeed, to make people feel they can’t eat anymore. I want people to walk away from Alpha feeling happy.”
Interiors whizz Paul Papadopoulos of DS17 (Nour, Mama Mulan) had excellent bones to work with when he set about reimagining the cavernous space. “Our main objective was to maintain the spirit of the existing restaurant and to not lose what everyone had fallen in love with previously,” says Papadopoulos.
The relaxed Grecian style is expressed via whitewashed walls, oak floors, Thonet chairs and layered grey fabrics. The more you look the more you realise that, as Papadopoulos says, “There’s a circle on everything”. There are Greek-inspired curves and arches on the enormous fluted marble bar, at the wait stations, in the timber work and in the bespoke marble table lamps. There’s not a sharp edge in sight.
The open, stage-like kitchen creates a theatrical backdrop to the dining experience, while the famed stone-panelled wall, deeply engraved with Greek letters, has been expanded to include two more that had been lost (Papadopoulos found them upstairs, in the bin). On the other side of the room, the backlit wine cellar is on display.
The old Alpha had a tiny kitchen; the new one has an elaborate open stage. The woodfired oven took eight years to get approved (it’s a heritage-listed building) and Conistis and head chef James Roberts (Beta Bar, ex-Salt Meats Cheese) are making the most of their new toy. “Now we've got it, we are embracing it. We are going crazy with it,” Conistis says.
In keeping with the Alpha tradition of fusing the old with the new, the menu features Greek classics with Conistisian twists. “I like to play on the familiar while also using very different flavours,” he says.
The bar menu offers osetra caviar imported from Greece and Conistis’s tongue-in-cheek take on pigs in blankets – Greek sausages wrapped in tsoureki (a sweet brioche-like bread). Behind the bar, Conistis’s Bloody Alpha is made with vodka infused with sundried tomatoes, fresh horseradish and chilli, and served on ice cubes made of tomato juice. Almost half of the wine list is Greek, while the remainder is Australian.
Ninety per cent of the menu is new. But there are three dishes that Conistis says will always be on the menu: his moussaka with scallops, a slow-roasted lamb and the much-loved original Alpha spanakopita. Conistis is following a nose-to-tail ethos, and no dish on the menu embodies that more than kokoretsi (a dish that is slated to be introduced to the menu in the coming weeks). Traditionally served at Easter, the dish is made by wrapping offal with sausage casing (rather than stuffing the casing with the offal) and served with a wild oregano and lemon dressing. Also on the menu is a suckling lamb on the spit, and a Greek-style spit-roast chicken that has been brined in feta, twice-cooked, and is served with a watermelon and feta salad. Conistis is also making smoked eggplant pies cooked over the woodfired oven. “Like a good Greek mama would do,” he says.
238 Castlereagh Street, Sydney
(02) 9098 1111
Wed to Fri 12pm–3pm, 5.30pm–9.30pm