Directory
  1. Sydney
  2. Food & Drink
Published 8 years ago

2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints

2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints
Mary's Pizzeria·Photo: Amy Heycock

Broadsheet covers culture and the people driving it. The latest and best in food & drink, art & design, fashion, entertainment and travel.

  • Melbourne
  • Sydney
  • Art & Design
  • Entertainment
  • Fashion
  • Food & Drink
  • Home & Lifestyle
  • Travel
  • City File
  • Things to Do
Directory

Food & Drink2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints

Fried pizzas in the colours of the Italian flag, a hidden 12-seat pizzeria in a dive pub, and cheesy pies that come with anchovies on the side.

Words by Sarah Norris And Yvonne C Lam · Updated on 21 Feb 2019 · Published on 19 Dec 2018

Sydney has proven yet again it’s one of the world’s great dining cities, with these new pizza places hitting their stride in an already competitive market. Sure, you could fly to Naples or New York, but you really don’t need to these days – there are plenty of local players pumping out pizzas on par with the world’s best, including these stellar joints that opened in 2018.

In 2018 we also had some big-name pizza guys visit to cook their versions of the cheesy bread discs – including Joe Beddia, whose Pizzeria Beddia – once named America’s best – popped up in Bondi , and Brooklyn’s Roberta’s took over Firedoor for one night only.

Pizza is always a good idea – if you haven’t tried these yet, add them to your list.

Bella Brutta
It feels so good when a ho-hum venue is replaced by an excellent one. It happened when the very strange Grill King carked it and fun-times bar Redfern Surf Club moved into its Alexandria space.

Then a very average pizza franchise in Newtown gave up its King Street address to a supergroup of LP’s Quality Meats and Porteno

More like this

Where Chefs Eat: 19 Top Chefs Share Sydney’s Best Specialty Grocers and Farmers Markets
Where Chefs Eat: 19 Top Chefs Share Sydney’s Best Specialty Grocers and Farmers Markets
Seven To Try: The Best Cardamom Buns in Sydney
Seven To Try: The Best Cardamom Buns in Sydney
Forget It’s Winter at These Four New Noodle Soup Shops
Forget It’s Winter at These Four New Noodle Soup Shops
  • Brisbane
  • Perth
  • Adelaide
  • London
    • About
    • Editorial standards
    • Social Media guidelines
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service

    © 2026 Broadsheet Media.
    Broadsheet is a trade mark used under licence by Broadsheet Media Pty Ltd from BM IP Pty Ltd as trustee for the BM IP Trust.

    restaurateurs. And what an ugly-to-beautiful transformation it’s been.

    Say hello to Bella Brutta, land of the clam pizza. That’s surf clams, fermented chilli, lemon juice, parsley and garlic oil, on a sourdough-ish base neither Neapolitan-style nor New York-style but crisp enough to withstand topping sag.

    The changing pizza selection runs the gamut of familiar to creative: tomatoes, garlic and basil; mortadella, green olives and fior di latte ; cavolo nero and confit garlic.

    If you want anchovies on your pizza you can choose how fancy and how much to spend: Olasagasti are $18; Don Bocarte also $18; smoked Nardin is $28. Technically they’re not on the pizza, though – the house prefers to keep those salty suckers unheated, so they come on the side.

    One Broadsheet staffer liked this place so much she visited twice in one night. If that’s not a ringing endorsement, we don’t know what is.

    Bonnie’s

    The one-person pizza fritta , or fried pizza – fried pizza! – at this venue within a venue is a crisp-on-the-outside, pillowy-on–the-inside delight. Plus at only $12 it’s a bargain.

    Executive chef Monty Koludrovic – who looks after Bonnie’s, the colourful 50-seater wine bar that opened in September inside Bondi Beach Public Bar (as well as across Icebergs and The Dolphin) – says the crisp base is first fried, then toppings are added before it’s finished in the woodfire oven, so it’s crunchy, toasty and hot. And, oh boy, it is.

    The toppings are changed regularly but there are always three pizzas available: red, white and green. “To make a nice little Italian flag when you buy all three of them,” he says.

    A killer (predominantly Australian) natural-wine list and eclectic soundtrack enhances the tasty experience.

    Mary’s Pizzeria
    Mary’s Pizzeria is possibly the only Sydney joint where you can get a pizza topped with fancy fior di latte and “crap shit” mozzarella. Where the dough and tomato sauce take a few days to make, before being covered in no-name pepperoni. Where you can order a “Tropical Fucker” (translation: ham-and-pineapple pizza) alongside a natural vino from Gippsland’s Unkel wines.

    The intimate 12-seat pizzeria (plus an additional private dining room where the pinball machines used to be) opened midway though this year inside Chippendale’s Lansdowne Hotel. Unlike the broader pub, it has table service, cloth napkins and candles. Cutlery is supplied should you choose to digress to the other menu offerings (pasta, salads, crudo), but the focus is the pizza – super thin New York rounds, or Detroit square style. The kitchen’s open till late, so we recommend consuming these handheld delights at midnight.

    Our pick? The spicy pepperoni. It’s the king of the trash pizza , says co-owner Jake Smyth. It’s square, with a bready, crunchy base and topped with three cheeses: fior di latte, low-moisture mozzarella in the middle (to preserve structural integrity), and high-fat mozzarella on the edges to create a delightful singed-cheese crust. It’s liberally laden with salty pepperoni discs, curled up at the edges from the oven heat. “It’s fucking crap pepperoni but we add heaps of it on,” Smyth told us.

    Matteo Downtown
    There is a surprising lack of decent pizza in the heart of corporate CBD Sydney, especially ones that are made in the doppio lievitazione style, where the dough is proved twice and naturally risen for 48 hours so there’s no yeast, resulting in light, elastic and extremely smashable bases.

    That’s what happens at the slick CBD outpost of Orazio D’Elia and co’s Double Bay eatery Matteo , which serves up an extensive list of Naples-style pizzas – everything from classics topped with San Marzano tomatoes, black olives, capers, anchovies, basil and fior di latte, to less traditional such as the one spread with pumpkin puree, and then crowned with cauliflower, oyster mushrooms and almonds.

    This place is huge – 600 square metres, in fact – with two woodfire ovens pumping out those steamy pizzas. If you’re there during aperitivo hour (Monday Friday 4pm to 6pm), complimentary snacks come with any drink order.

    Need more pizza in your life? Here’s Broadsheet’s guide to the best in town. Or want to try a specific regional pizza? Read this.

    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Advertise
    • Feedback
    • Contribute
    • Shop
    • instagram
    • tiktok
    • facebook
    • linkedin
    • pinterest
    Directory

    Food & Drink2018’s Best New Sydney Pizza Joints

    Log inSubscribe

    More from Broadsheet

    The Red Centre’s First International Dark Sky Sanctuary Is Worth the Trip
    The Red Centre’s First International Dark Sky Sanctuary Is Worth the Trip
    Travel
    Karlu Karlu, or the Devils Marbles, is officially one of the best stargazing spots in Australia – and the world. In partnership with Tourism Central Australia, this itinerary makes the most of a trip there.
    The Smarter Guide to Wedding Guest Dressing
    The Smarter Guide to Wedding Guest Dressing
    Fashion
    From the dress code to the 3am dance floor, here’s how to show up polished and stay that way. In partnership with Philips, we break down the smart wedding-guest wardrobe – and the two-in-one tool that keeps it crease-free.
    Cafes, Clubs, and Cascading Falls: Xflos Florist Kayla Moon’s Favourite Spots To Find Inspiration
    Cafes, Clubs, and Cascading Falls: Xflos Florist Kayla Moon’s Favourite Spots To Find Inspiration
    Art & Design
    Ideas for her daring creations come from the most unexpected places. In partnership with GWM ANZ, here’s where Moon finds colour and creativity across Melbourne and surrounds.
    Could Mushroom Leather Be the Future of Fashion? A New NGV Exhibition Explores the Possibility
    Could Mushroom Leather Be the Future of Fashion? A New NGV Exhibition Explores the Possibility
    Art & Design
    Plant Life: The Nature of Design, presented in partnership with NGV's Futures Partner, RMIT University is all about looking to nature for the sustainable designs of the future. We chat with two forward-thinking designers about their “leather” made from fungi and the other cool innovations you can check out.
    Designing the Ultimate Home Kitchen? Shannon Bennett Has Some Tips
    Designing the Ultimate Home Kitchen? Shannon Bennett Has Some Tips
    Food & Drink
    Want your home kitchen to run with the clockwork precision of a restaurant? In partnership with Miele, the celebrity chef gives us some advice – and a look into his home kitchen in Byron Bay.
    Ditch the Chocolate Bar: Upgrade Your Afternoon Snack With These Simple Berry Sweet Treat Recipes
    Ditch the Chocolate Bar: Upgrade Your Afternoon Snack With These Simple Berry Sweet Treat Recipes
    Food & Drink
    Satisfy your afternoon sweet tooth with these quick, berry-based snacks that are easy to prep ahead. In partnership with Driscoll’s, here are three recipes that won’t give you post-snack guilt.
    Five Reasons To Visit Newcastle Art Gallery
    Five Reasons To Visit Newcastle Art Gallery
    Art & Design
    Head to Sydney’s coastal neighbour this spring and summer for contemporary art and live music. In partnership with City of Newcastle, we map out your ultimate guide.
    Win: A Year’s Supply of Wine, With Delivery to Your Door Every Season
    Win: A Year’s Supply of Wine, With Delivery to Your Door Every Season
    Food & Drink
    Make some room on the wine rack: one lucky wine-lover will receive 48 bottles to enjoy across the year.

    Videos

    Five Minutes With Doom Juice, the Slightly Satanic Sydney Wine Label04:33

    Five Minutes With Doom Juice, the Slightly Satanic Sydney Wine Label

    The Art of Service: There's Something for Everyone at Moon Mart01:00

    The Art of Service: There's Something for Everyone at Moon Mart

    Revving for Ramen: How Sydney's Rising Sun Workshop Fuels Connection Through Food02:18

    Revving for Ramen: How Sydney's Rising Sun Workshop Fuels Connection Through Food

    More Guides

    Recipes

    Recipe: Davidson’s-Plum-Glazed Lamb Ribs From Culinary Duo Analiese Gregory and Clayton Wells
    Recipe: Davidson’s-Plum-Glazed Lamb Ribs From Culinary Duo Analiese Gregory and Clayton Wells
    Recipe: A Peppery Native Ingredient-Driven Dressing for Fresh Oysters
    Recipe: A Peppery Native Ingredient-Driven Dressing for Fresh Oysters
    Recipe: Chase Kojima’s Oyster Vinaigrette (and How to Shuck)
    Recipe: Chase Kojima’s Oyster Vinaigrette (and How to Shuck)