COMMENT
Emily Watson is the founder and designer of her eponymous Melbourne fashion label.
I’m six years into running my eponymous fashion label, Emily Watson, and I’ve decided to do a 180. Wholesale has been the lifeblood of the business, but now I’m pulling back.
I started my brand in 2020. It was a Covid project, born from too much free time, a recently finished RMIT fashion design honours degree and access to my local Tafe’s fashion tools and machinery. The stylist for American rapper Rico Nasty reached out to me for a press opportunity. After that vote of confidence, I decided to sell some of the dress designs she’d worn through stockists. My first was Melbourne boutique Distal Phalanx.
The brand’s first year was pretty unbelievable. I really felt like I was living the dream – Bella Hadid, Emma Chamberlain and Camila Mendes all wore my pieces.
While juggling this rapid growth and public praise, I was still trying to figure out the business side of things. I didn’t learn about pricing at uni, so I fumbled through it. I learnt that stockists usually take about 50 to 60 per cent of a garment’s retail price, and designers get the remaining 40 to 50 per cent.
Every stockist is different, but typically these retailers will purchase a bulk order of products at wholesale price, usually with a down payment. I’d make the clothes and ship them to the retailer. When they received the product, they’d pay me the balance, typically within the 30-day payment term, but it wasn’t uncommon to have to wait longer.
I was used to fulfilling some of these big wholesale orders with a down payment of as little as 10 to 30 per cent of the order, which covers only a small portion of production costs (standard down payments run anywhere between 30 to 50 per cent of the order value). That meant creating an order, worth tens of thousands of dollars, out of pocket. Without getting a loan from family, I wouldn’t have been able to finish production for jobs like these.
My pricing had to increase when I took on bigger, global retailers. These international luxury platforms had a bigger mark-up than I was used to (adding around 60 per cent to the item's price) and they asked for additional discounts. An initial two per cent discount might sound small, but when an order is worth $25,000, it adds up quickly. One retailer eventually asked for a 10 per cent discount. Other similar retailers added on marketing fees, requesting a 20 per cent discount so they could market me as a small brand. The irony!
Another wholesale order with a global retailer didn’t go ahead – the payment terms they proposed were difficult for me to work with as a small business and highlighted how the cashflow realities of large wholesale accounts can be very different for an emerging brand.
A couple of years into my business, I had six to eight retailers at once, which was a lot for a brand mostly manufacturing in-house. (Other brands may outsource some elements of the production process, allowing them to manage simultaneous orders from several accounts.)
Despite my grievances, there was a lot of good to come out of those partnerships. I gained trust with customers, as appearing on those platforms was like having a gold star next to my name. A lot of people discovered my label on these platforms and then shared customer photos on social media, which helped my reach. There are a lot of positives that come with selling through big retail giants, but for my label’s long-term success, I knew I couldn’t go on at that pace and volume.
It felt like I was running my business for these platforms. I had to scale up specifically for them – at one point I even had an employee who was largely employed to fulfil a single order. I didn’t feel like an independent brand anymore. It felt like we were a manufacturer. Over time, it ruined the spark for me.
Last year was a particularly hard year for the business. A large stockist pushed back a delivery by three to four months, meaning that the balance payment for the order would also be paid that late. That cashflow insecurity and stress were the last straw – I knew I had to change something.
I was looking at ways to optimise profits, but I didn’t want to compromise by using cheaper fabric or production, or by degrading the designs. It made the most sense to me to cut out the wholesale mark-up, so I could maximise my profits and reduce prices for customers.
In June this year, I cut ties with large wholesalers. I now prioritise my direct-to-consumer business and work with some carefully selected stockists – boutique retailers who align with my values, and are usually more understanding and flexible with arrangements from payment terms to delivery.
Importantly, this change allowed me to reduce all of my garment prices by 15 to 25 per cent permanently.
Sales have improved, and it feels like my customers trust me more since I became more candid about the industry. People seem to know that prices are now as close to the cost of the garment as they can be.
I’m an indecisive person, and I don’t really like change. It scares me a lot. The wholesale production system was all I’d ever known, but I could feel my spirit dying a bit. The move away from supplying to big retailers has been a relief and felt inspiring. It’s given me a little bit of control back, and I have a lot more creative freedom. I’ve got room to breathe again.
Broadsheet publishes a range of opinion stories from independent contributors. The ideas and views expressed in these pieces don’t reflect those of Broadsheet or its staff.
More from Broadsheet
Videos
More Guides
Recipes