Penny Young started as a bottle shop, but scored a beer hall next door in 2018. The indoor-meets-outdoor space is all about natural light. Beneath a retractable roof, there’s stripped-back wood, exposed beams, copper fittings and a mural by Richmond tattoo artist Simple Sime.

A mixture of high-and-low wood tables and old beer barrels are dotted about. The bar top and other bits of furniture are made from timber recovered from one of Melbourne’s oldest houses, Wentworth House.

There are 17 beers and one cider on tap. You’ll find a mixture of local craft from the likes of CoConspirators, La Sirene, and Fury and Sons. A few mainstream beers and internationals, such as Birra Moretti, round out the list. There also are a dozen or so wines by the glass – mostly local – and a few bottle options, and you can purchase any bottle over $25 from the expansive selection in the shop next door. Corkage is charged on top.

The food menu features eight pizza rossa and eight pizza bianca, cooked with sparse toppings and lots of fior di latte in what Bongiovanni calls “the Rolls-Royce of pizza ovens” – a Marra Forni imported from Italy. The Quattro Formaggi (fior di latte, gorgonzola, pecorino and goat’s cheese) will please cheese lovers, and the carb-on-carb Patate E Mozzarella (potato, rosemary, fior di latte, pecorino and garlic oil) features pillowy potato, fior di latte, pecorino, and rosemary. Classics such as Margherita, Napoli and Capricciosa are all there. The menu also includes other Italian plates, such as antipasto and beef-and-red-wine meatballs.

In the original bottle shop there are 350-plus beers, but the long, open-faced fridge turns a potentially tough series of decisions into an easy shopping experience. Cans and bottles from Australian brewers such as Colonial, Feral and La Sirène are all present. Limited release bottles such as Hargreaves Hill Phoenix Imperial Red Ale, or Moondog’s Jumping The Shark, will tempt many to up their shopping spend. Wine is similarly well represented.

Contact Details

Updated: March 31st, 2023

We do not seek or accept payment from the cafes, restaurants, bars and shops listed in the Directory – inclusion is at our discretion. Venue profiles are written by independent freelancers paid by Broadsheet.