Best Basque Burnt Cheesecakes in Melbourne

Lasagne is Australia’s national crisis dish, sourdough is our ride-or-die isolation bread (although Japanese shokupan is nipping at its heels) and babka is our perfect lockdown dessert.

But Basque burnt cheesecake – all caramelised and glossy on the outside, wobbly and custardy on the inside – is the breakout cake. For the uninitiated, it’s less sweet than its North American relative, the New York cheesecake, and also lacks a biscuit-y base. That makes it dangerous in the best possible way: it’s easy to hoover up one of these things in no time at all. Here are our favourites.

Words by
Updated on 23 September 2021

Shop

Morning Market Fitzroy

This one is a bestseller. Don’t take your chances hoping there’ll be one in-store – pre-order online and pick up at Morning Market in Fitzroy or Prahran to avoid cheesecake heartbreak.

Shop

Q le Baker

Also in Prahran: this very fine take on the cheesecake. It comes in small ($25) and large ($60) – but we recommend large. It's better to have too much Basque cheesecake than not enough.

Shop

Burch and Purchese Sweet Studio

It was never going to be long before serial reinventor Darren Purchese, one of the city’s most famous pastry chefs, put his stamp on the Basque cheesecake. Available online Tuesday to Sunday, his $60 version includes a layer of tangy lemon curd baked through the middle.

Restaurant

Attica

Of course Melbourne’s best restaurant is in on the takeaway Basque cheesecake game. This one is made with three types of cream: mascarpone, pouring and cream cheese. It’s also one of the largest cheesecakes in this guide, dividing into eight generous slices.

Cafe

Calere

Down the street from Morning Market Fitzroy, Calere sells caramelised pineapple Basque burnt cheesecakes. In Taiwan, caramelised pineapple cakes are often given as gifts for engagements, promotions and other special occasions. Those flavours are here added to the Basque cheesecake – and the result is worth celebrating. The original’s also on offer, for those who prefer the classic.

Restaurant

Sebastian

Sebastian's Basque burnt cheesecake is a total doozy. And, being a Basque diner, it has a good claim to having started – or at least heavily contributed to – Melbourne's current obsession with this sub-genre of cheesecake. Order one online or find a local stockist here, including Toscano’s and Scicluna’s in the eastern and southeastern suburbs.

Cafe

Papirica

Throughout lockdown Akira Toyama has been baking cheesecakes at Papirica under the name Only Cheesecake. Her signature is a miso and sesame number, but she also makes an excellent Basque cheesecake, which is available by the slice at Papirica or Mile End.

Restaurant

Philippe

Even though it’s typically associated with Spain, the Basque region actually stretches into the south-western tip of France. So a classic French restaurant doing a riff on this cheesecake isn’t as strange as it seems. And at $50, this big one is great value.

Cafe

Proper & Son

This South Melbourne Market fixture bakes its own fantastic – and frankly adorable – Basque burnt cheesecakes. Stop by next time you're getting your groceries and check the cabinet to see if they're there.

Shop

Ovens Street

It’s almost perpetually unavailable and when it is, you can only find it on a Friday, but darn it if this isn’t a cheesecake worth holding out for. Refresh this page in hope of a restock.

Shop

Back Alley Bakes

It doesn’t get more hole-in-the-wall than this backstreet bakery, which started as a lockdown project. Its roller door rises early to serve sourdough loaves, flaky croissants and a knockout sausage-roll-croissant hybrid.

Other Notable Cheesecakes Around Town

Señor Simon Cheesecakes
This Northcote-based baker generally makes his cheesecakes wholesale for a handful of cafes and shops, but on Thursdays and Fridays, he'll deliver to you. Order through Instagram.

Better Burnt
If the pandemic has proved anything, it's that there's a niche Instagram account for everything. So of course Melbourne has its own online-only Basque cheesecake delivery service. Better Burnt offers either mini or full-sized cheesecakes to order. The mini, muffin-sized cakes come in boxes of six, nine or 12. (August mini cake slots have already sold out, but you can still order full-sized versions). There are also lactose-free options. Order via Instagram.

Sugar Nomad
Instagram-born bakery Sugar Nomad takes the dessert’s Spanish origins and injects some Asian influences. Pastry chef Ivy Yap bakes a handful of flavours. There’s the standout hojicha and a vibrant green matcha, as well as Thai milk tea, coffee and the OG. Order via DM for delivery within 20 kilometres of Bulleen, or pick-up at Ima Project Cafe or Dodee Paidang.

Sucette
This Moorabbin-based online shop specialises in canelés – a cylindrical rum and vanilla-flavoured pastry from Bordeaux, but its $45 Basque cheesecakes have slowly been edging their way into the limelight. Alongside the classic flavour, consider the cacao-flavoured Basque cheesecake which (very successfully) adds dark chocolate to the mix.

Northern Ground, Bairnsdale
This Bairnsdale restaurant bakes all of its sweets in-house, including this ripper of a cheesecake. The only problem is that the team here can barely keep up with demand. We can see why. Even if you're based in metro Melbourne and you can't make it to Bairnsdale right now, it's worth putting this place on your radar.

Nature's Cakes, Healesville
This classic cake and coffee shop does all of the bakehouse staples well, but its foray into Basque cheesecakes has been particularly successful. Check it out if you're in the area.

More Guides